The minutes of today's short call are available at:
... and copied as text below.
If you haven't done so yet, please indicate if you will attend next F2F
Adam is to start the review on the last call comments received for
Mobile Web Application Best Practices:
Decisions on the comments received for the Guidelines for Web Content
Transformation Proxies were postponed in Eduardo's absence.
Next week's call is canceled for lack of chairs.
Next call is thus on Tuesday 24 November 2009.
10 Nov 2009
See also: IRC log
francois, yeliz, jo, adam, DKA, miguel, Kai, SeanP, chaals
jeffs, brucel, sangwhan, tomhume, manrique, EdC
1. London F2F
3. Content Transformation
* Summary of Action Items
<francois> F2F registration results so far
Jo: If you haven't done so yet, please indicate if you will attend
Jo: Lots of good comments just this morning.
<francois> list of last call comments on MWABP (member-only)
Jo: Just arrived on BP-comments list.
<francois> Initial comments from Marc Wilson
Jo: Where are we with latest editorial revisions.
Adam: I've started - hope to cover them this weeks.
... What do to with comments?
Jo: If you want to make some initial responses that would help.
We'll discuss as a group before replying.
François: No need to be that formal. If you want to reply to Mark
directly on the comments list that would be fine. Might be better to
engage with commenters earlier.
<francois> ACTION: adam to review comments from Marc Wilson and
trigger discussion as needed [recorded in
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1024 - Review comments from Marc Wilson
and trigger discussion as needed [on Adam Connors - due 2009-11-17].
Jo: Status of replies - we haven't had many.
François: we need to chase people down. We had many comments on the
initial last call wd - we must know if they approve or not our final
decision. I will take an action to chase people down.
<francois> ACTION: daoust to try to get replies from commenters of
the first last call working draft of CT [recorded in
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1025 - Try to get replies from commenters
of the first last call working draft of CT [on François Daoust - due
+1 on Bruce's presentation [saw it at FOWA].
Jo: Ed's comments. Worth deferring discussion until he is here.
... I think we face a choice at this stage on moving ahead with this
or having it stay in LC forever.
François: We shouldn't worry right now on group not being chartered
Jo: Would another group be prepared to take it on?
François: only plan would be charter extension.
Jo: I am not in favour of making substantive changes... I don't
think the document will ever finish if we don't finish it...
Chaals: If there are required substantive changes then I think we
will have a difficult time getting the group consider to go on... I
think we need to at some time grapple with Ed's issues.
<SeanP> +1 to not making radical changes to the CT Guidelines
Jo: I agree but Ed's issues are additional issues. We should
consider his contributions but should we decide to enact them then
that would [kill] the document.
Chaals: the way to avoid that is to grapple with the issues and
resolve that we don't have any action to take on them.
+1 to not making radical changes.
+1 to ending the group on time if at all possible.
Jo: Contributions of tests - anything else to say?
Dan: won't we need a charter extension anyway to shepherd the docs
François: Yes. The group won't have much to do during this time but
we will need the group to be operating for administrative reasons.
Jo: Suggest François find out what we will need to do.
François: Would be similar to how DD operated.
<chaals> bye.. thanks Jo, Dan
Jo: In all likelyhood next week's call will be cancelled [due to
lack of chairs].
Summary of Action Items
[NEW] ACTION: adam to review comments from Marc Wilson and trigger
discussion as needed [recorded in
[NEW] ACTION: daoust to try to get replies from commenters of the
first last call working draft of CT [recorded in
[End of minutes]
|Free forum by Nabble||Edit this page|